THE LONG INSURGENCY // OPEN-SOURCE CASE FILE // EVERY THREAD ON THIS BOARD IS A FOOTNOTE
Counter-Revolutionary ArchiveSubscribe

Source record · Reference only

Source file · TLI-SRC-0039

TLI-SRC-0039 // Archived original

The Education of a Reluctant Radical

Carl Marzani

Reference onlyNo copy or public link

Holding state

Access

The archive does not hold this document.

Cited edition: New York: Topical Books, five volumes, 1992-1995.

Catalog card

Bibliographic record

Title
The Education of a Reluctant Radical
Author
Carl Marzani
Year
five volumes, 1992-1995
Document type
Book
Source class
1. Primary text (the thinker’s own work)
Standpoint
Movement: writes from inside the tradition
Publisher
Topical Books
Place
New York

Standard numbers

Identifiers

No standard identifiers are recorded.

Quoted evidence

The Passages

  1. Passage 01Verified against the document (edition named)

    The Open Marxism of ANTONIO GRAMSCI translated and annotated by CARL MARZANI CAMERON ASSOCIATES, INC. · NEW YORK · 1957

    {"offset": 135172}

    THE PAGE IMAGE WAS READ, not only the text layer. Printed page 67 of Book 3, in the chapter 'Meeting Marx', carries a facsimile of the booklet's own title page inside a ruled box: 'The Open Marxism / of / ANTONIO GRAMSCI / translated and annotated / by / CARL MARZANI', and beneath a small printer's device, 'CAMERON ASSOCIATES, INC. - NEW YORK - 1957'. The scan's text layer renders that device as a pound sign and the two centred dots as a guillemet and a plus sign; the device is dropped and the dots restored from the image, and nothing else in the quoted span is altered. The sentence around the facsimile begins on page 66, 'My small book, The Open Marxism of', and resumes below the box, 'Antonio Gramsci (New York, Cameron Associates, 1957), introduced him to the American public'; the running head 'MEETING MARX 67' is removed and the line-break hyphen in 'introduced' closed up. The same page is in the corpus at work:w679ab9a1d009fd1a, offset 135172, which is Book 3 of this memoir. THE DATE IS THE POINT: this title page reads 1957, and so does Marzani's own sentence around it, while John Cammett's essay in this same volume cites the booklet as '(New York: Cameron Associates, 1958)' in its second note. Secondary accounts give 1957, 1958 and 1959. The reproduced title page is the document and it says 1957.

  2. Passage 02Verified against the document (edition named)

    Really the only substantial publication before 1960 by an American was Carl Marzani’s sixty-four-page annotated translation of passages from the Prison Notebooks.

    {"offset": 517814}

    Read in the copy on the shelf, printed page 271, the opening of Cammett's essay in the appendix to Book 3. The same text is in the corpus at work:w679ab9a1d009fd1a, offset 517814, character for character including the line-break hyphen in 'translation', which is closed up here. THIS IS CAMMETT, NOT MARZANI, and it is the only place the archive can read the booklet's extent: sixty-four pages. It is a scholar's essay printed in the memoir, so this element of the claim is one step removed even though it stands in a primary source; the booklet itself is not in the corpus and has no copy on the shelf. Cammett's own second note to this essay cites the booklet as '(New York: Cameron Associates, 1958)', which the reproduced title page on page 67 of the same volume contradicts. A footnote marker follows 'Prison Notebooks.' on the page and falls outside the quoted span.

Claim ledger

Cited By

  1. documented

    The Open Marxism of Antonio Gramsci, a sixty-four-page selection translated and annotated by Carl Marzani, was published by Cameron Associates in New York in 1957. The title page is reproduced in Marzani’s own memoir, which settles a date that secondary sources give variously as 1957, 1958 and 1959.

    Filed in: Dossier: Antonio Gramsci · Dossier: Carl Marzani · Dossier: Prison Notebooks

  2. reported

    Marzani writes that he takes great pride in being the first to translate Gramsci from Italian into English. Hobsbawm credits Louis Marks’s The Modern Prince (London, 1956) as probably the first selection of Gramsci’s writings in a non-Italian language, a year earlier. The archive reports the conflict rather than resolving it: Marzani is likely first in America, and the plain claim of first-in-English does not survive Hobsbawm.

    Filed in: Dossier: Carl Marzani · Dossier: Prison Notebooks

  3. reported

    Marzani records that his 1957 booklet sparked the interest of John Cammett, then a graduate student, who became the leading American scholar of Gramsci.

    Filed in: Dossier: Carl Marzani · Dossier: John Cammett

Copy condition

Integrity

No integrity notes are recorded.

← Return to the source catalog